Credibility and Logic in Gregory Curfman’s “Diet Pills Redux”

1. Gregory D. Curfman’s piece â€Å"Diet Pills Redux† is a publication; in this manner, a peruser must remember that the substance will concentrate on the author’s opinion(s) and perspective(s) about a specific circumstance. Having perused Curfman’s piece, it appears to be believable. The creator is a doctor, so his examination of the circumstance can be sensibly accepted inside his field of aptitude, particularly when one considers it is a publication distributed in The New England Journal of Medicine. Dr.Curfman presents proof for and against the utilization of fenfluramine and phentermine and appears to be concerned uniquely with further investigation of a potential association between the utilization of these medications (independently or together) and coronary illness (Curfman, 1997, passim).2. Curfman starts his piece with an outline of an episode of pneumonic hypertension that occurred in Western Europe that was connected to the utilization of a cra ving suppressant sedate. He proceeds to uncover an European episode thirty years after the fact which associated the utilization of an anorectic medication with more instances of pneumonic hypertension.Later, he talks about gauging the dangers of utilizing anorectic medications against the individual’s need, and infers that just those with no other response ought to be permitted to take the risk. Each of these is a case of rationale without false notion (Curfman, 1997, passim). There were paradoxes in Curfman’s piece. In any case, the occasions and studies he refered to were missing benchmark groups and affirmations that urgent factors, for example, understanding history had been considered. In fact, these may be interpreted as misdirecting statistics.Because the quantities of people adversely affected by these medications was so low, the possible that quite a bit of his point is maybe a non sequiturâ€specifically a contention based on a dangerous incline exists. Hi s end comment that â€Å"succumbing to the charm of diet pills as a handy solution for overabundance weight might be pursuing disaster† presents a noteworthy legitimate issue: the suggestion that the individuals who endured a heart emergency regarding the utilization of at least one of the included medications fall into the â€Å"quick fix† categoryâ€this is a hurried speculation (Curfman, 1997, passim).The generally speaking message in the piece was not that accuse must be laid, nor was it a call to end all accessibility of either sedate, so combined with this piece being a publication, even false notion didn't really debilitate the quality of the article as I would see it as the point appeared to be only to be to persuade perusers that there was more to be examined. In light of what I read, I need to concur that further examination is justified and that shoppers must know about the potential risks recorded by Curfman.